Gotham Bar and Grill, located at 12 E. 12th Street, in Greenwich Village, serves contemporary American cuisine. Upon entering the restaurant, you’ll notice a long bar to the left, with tables to the right and back. It really is more restaurant than bar. At lunch, it is filled with business executives and their clients. Still, it retains a rather quiet, low-key atmosphere. The dress code is what I would call business casual at lunch, and perhaps a little dressier at dinner.
The prices don’t differ much between the lunch and dinner menus for appetizers, with a couple of notable exceptions. A la carte appetizers are in the $20 range, while entrees are about $25. In addition to a la carte lunch items, there is a budget-friendly two-course prix fixe option available for $25. The prix fixe menu offers a choice one of three appetizers, and one of three entrees. Many of the items on the lunch menu are seafood, though meat and vegetarian options are available. The prix fixe lunch menu is very vegetarian-friendly.
At dinner, caviar is available as a starter, for upwards of $100. Expect to pay in the neighborhood of $35-$50 for a dinner entrée. Although not a seafood restaurant, seafood also features prominently on its dinner menu. Other options include duck, chicken, beef, and lamb. Vegetarian options include a salad or risotto.
I have never had a bad meal at Gotham Bar and Grill. The food is always impeccably cooked and presented. As much as I love duck, I have always ordered seafood. This is simply because when I eat out, I tend to order something I would make infrequently at home, and with not nearly as much panache as a professional chef.
Dessert items are approximately $15 each. Gotham Bar and Grill has an excellent pastry chef, but my favorite is the cheese plate. Several different artisanal cheeses are served with nut bread, jam, and crackers.
Service is excellent. The wait staff is attentive without being intrusive. There’s no undue wait for the food, nor is there any pressure to eat up and get out of there, so they can turn over the table. I would suggest making reservations for dinner, but it is probably not necessary at lunch.